Summary
Rosemary Grey, an international criminal law researcher at the University of Sydney, examines one of the less frequently investigated dimensions of violence against girls recruited as child soldiers in an article published in the Leiden Journal of International Law. Drawing on judicial cases from Sierra Leone, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Uganda and Colombia, she demonstrates how forced pregnancy, forced abortion, denial of healthcare and control over girls’ family lives within armed groups may escape independent criminal prosecution. The findings, particularly concerning violence within armed groups, restrictions on leaving and command responsibility, overlap with issues raised in cases documented by Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch and highlight the need for more detailed documentation of these experiences.
Introduction: A Researcher Examining Overlooked Crimes
In many international cases, the fate of children recruited into armed groups begins with one question: Who sent them to war? But Rosemary Grey, an international criminal law researcher and Senior Lecturer at the University of Sydney Law School, pursues another question as well: Between a child’s recruitment and their departure from an armed group, what forms of violence might have occurred without ever becoming the subject of separate criminal charges?
Grey received her PhD from the University of New South Wales in Australia and, between 2016 and 2018, worked as a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Melbourne Law School. She subsequently joined the University of Sydney, where her research has focused on international criminal law, sexual and gender-based crimes, reproductive violence and criminal responsibility in armed conflict. Her book, Prosecuting Sexual and Gender-Based Crimes at the International Criminal Court, was published by Cambridge University Press in 2019.
Grey’s professional experience extends beyond academia. She has worked with organisations including Amnesty International and the Women’s Initiatives for Gender Justice, conducted research at the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC), and, alongside several human rights organisations, provided an expert legal opinion on the crime of forced pregnancy in the case of Dominic Ongwen, a commander of the Lord’s Resistance Army in Uganda. Her research on reproductive crimes in Cambodia has also received funding from the Australian Research Council.
Her latest article, entitled Reproductive Violence against Child Soldiers, was published online on 10 April 2026 in the Leiden Journal of International Law. It appeared in Volume 39, Issue 2, June 2026, on pages 563–587. The specialist international law journal is associated with Cambridge University Press and the Grotius Centre for International Legal Studies at Leiden University and is a recognised publication in international legal scholarship.
The article is published as open access, making independent examination and assessment possible. However, as of the preparation of this report, there was insufficient evidence to assess its academic reception or whether it had received widespread independent attention.
The article’s significance lies above all in its research method. Rather than presenting a general list of forms of violence, Grey returns to publicly available court records to demonstrate how certain victim experiences have been documented in judicial proceedings but have not been given independent standing in the final formulation of charges.
The War That Begins After a Child Is Recruited
The familiar image of a child soldier is that of an adolescent holding a rifle and fighting on the front line. Grey begins her article by challenging this narrow image. She writes that developments in legal scholarship have shown that children associated with armed forces and armed groups are not limited to those who participate directly in combat. They may perform tasks such as carrying ammunition, guarding positions, delivering messages, preparing food or undertaking support activities, while simultaneously facing various forms of abuse.
This distinction is particularly important for girls. Alongside military training and combat-related activities, some girls are forced to perform domestic labour, engage in coerced sexual relationships or live with commanders who designate them as their “wives”. Under such circumstances, a girl may simultaneously become a victim of child recruitment, deprivation of liberty, sexual exploitation and reproductive violence.
The Paris Principles, adopted in 2007, define children associated with armed forces and armed groups more broadly than direct participation in hostilities, covering individuals under the age of 18. By contrast, the crime of conscripting or using child soldiers under the Rome Statute, subject to its prescribed conditions, focuses on children under the age of 15. Grey recalls this distinction to demonstrate that child protection and the possibility of prosecuting a specific crime do not always involve the same age thresholds or legal requirements.
This discussion is relevant to issues examined by Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch in recent years. In the account of “Hira”, an adolescent girl who, according to an interview published by the organisation, came into contact with the Party for a Free Life of Kurdistan (PAK) at the age of 15, she describes her experience in a military environment, restrictions on contact with her family, pressure to marry and difficulties leaving the organisation.
In another report, Kaveh Shahbazi recounted that, as an adolescent, he was encouraged to join Komala through Instagram, with promises of employment, housing and financial resources. After arriving, he encountered conditions that differed from what had been promised. This case does not concern reproductive violence, but it demonstrates that examining the recruitment process alone is insufficient to understand a child’s situation within an armed group.
The more important question is what happens to a child’s right to choose, freedom of movement, family contact and physical and psychological safety after joining.
Reproductive Violence: A Crime Not Always Recognised as Sexual Violence
Grey explains the concept of reproductive violence in terms of violations of an individual’s autonomy in making decisions about reproduction: whether to have children, when to become pregnant and with whom to have a child.
Within this framework, reproductive violence is not limited to pregnancy resulting from rape. Forced abortion, the imposition of contraceptive methods and denial of essential reproductive healthcare may also constitute forms of reproductive violence.
The author notes that the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court addressed reproductive violence as a distinct concern in its 2023 Policy on Gender-Based Crimes. The Rome Statute also expressly provides for forced pregnancy and enforced sterilisation, subject to specific legal conditions, as war crimes and crimes against humanity. Preventing births within a protected group may also be examined as genocide if the other required elements are established.
However, not every form of reproductive violence is expressly designated as a separate crime under the Statute. This is precisely where part of Grey’s research becomes significant: how can conduct that does not have an independent criminal designation be examined under existing legal categories while respecting the principle of legality in criminal law?
This distinction is also important when examining armed groups. Forced marriage, by itself, does not establish forced pregnancy. Similarly, restrictions on movement or prohibitions on contact with family members, without further information, are insufficient to prove reproductive violence. Nevertheless, such circumstances may create an environment of coercion and dependency that makes it necessary to examine whether an individual’s consent and freedom of decision-making were genuine.
In Hira’s account, pressure to marry one of the PAK commanders and the alleged forced marriage of a girl named “Delzhin” after an attempted escape are raised. These accounts are relevant to examining forced marriage, unequal power relations and the possibility of making free decisions. However, establishing specific reproductive crimes would require independent evidence concerning conduct related to reproduction.
Sierra Leone: A Girl Who Was Both a Soldier and a Victim
One of the principal examples in the article concerns the testimony of a girl in proceedings involving the armed forces in Sierra Leone, recorded under the identifier TF1-094 in the records of the country’s Special Court. She was approximately 12 years old when she was abducted. During captivity, she received weapons training, was used in activities related to the conflict and was simultaneously assigned as the “wife” of an armed group member.
For her, this designation did not represent a freely chosen family relationship. Instead, it involved sexual abuse and forced domestic labour. She became pregnant after a short period. During the sixth month of pregnancy, when physical pain prevented her from accompanying the other forces, she was beaten by a commander. Her baby was stillborn.
Grey explains that several forms of violence can be examined in this account: pregnancy resulting from coercion, deprivation of liberty during pregnancy, pressure to continue the pregnancy and the possible connection between the abuse and the death of the foetus. However, she does not present a causal relationship between the beating and the stillbirth as an established fact.
Another example is the testimony of Akiatu Tuli in the Charles Taylor case. She was abducted before the age of 14, received military training, was forced to use drugs and was also raped. She described three pregnancies resulting from sexual violence, the first two of which ended in spontaneous miscarriages. The third pregnancy ended in hospital after she had left captivity, although the public records do not clarify how her informed consent to the procedure was obtained.
The significance of these cases is that violence against the girls did not occur in only one role or setting. The same individual who was recruited to carry weapons and perform military tasks was also subjected to domination and abuse within the group’s internal environment.
The author concludes that focusing exclusively on child recruitment or sexual slavery may cause specific dimensions of reproductive violence and their independent consequences to disappear from judicial proceedings.
The Democratic Republic of the Congo: When Evidence Exists but Charges Are Not Brought
The case of Thomas Lubanga before the International Criminal Court is one of the article’s most important examples. Lubanga was tried for conscripting and using children under the age of 15 in an armed conflict. However, during the proceedings, testimony was also presented concerning rape, pregnancy and abortion among girls belonging to his armed group.
One witness stated that commanders decided whether pregnant girls could remain in the camp and that some girls resorted to abortion to avoid expulsion. The witness also described the death of a 14-year-old girl following an attempted abortion. However, Grey specifies in her references that the court found this same witness’s testimony unreliable. Her account must therefore not be treated as a judicially established finding.
Another witness, who worked in child protection, spoke of girls who had been expelled from the group after becoming pregnant as a result of rape. Upon returning to society, they faced social stigma, medical problems and the responsibility of raising children without support from their fathers.
Despite these issues being raised, the ICC was unable to convict Lubanga for sexual and reproductive violence. The main problem was that the facts relating to this conduct had not been included within the scope of the case at the stage when the charges were confirmed. The procedural rules did not permit new charges to be added solely on the basis of facts that emerged for the first time during the trial.
As a result, a case that was historically significant for its conviction concerning child soldier recruitment could not address all the harm alleged to have been inflicted on girls.
This experience offers a practical lesson for human rights documentation organisations: the completeness of a victim’s initial account and the preservation of relevant evidence may prove decisive at later stages.
In cases documented by Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch, including Hira’s testimony concerning restrictions on leaving, pressure to marry, interrogation and detention, the value of documentation lies in more than recording a general account. The dates of events, the individual’s age when each act occurred, the commanders’ positions, the possibility of leaving the camp, the existence of independent witnesses and any potential medical records may all be significant in subsequent legal examination.
Ntaganda: Can an Armed Group Commit War Crimes Against Its Own Members?
The case of Bosco Ntaganda before the International Criminal Court represents one of the turning points in Grey’s analysis. In this case, in addition to other crimes, sexual violence against girls who themselves belonged to the same armed group was examined. The defence argued that crimes committed by members of an armed force against other members of that same force did not fall within the scope of international humanitarian law or international criminal law.
This argument was rejected. The Court confirmed that rape and sexual slavery within an armed group can also constitute war crimes, provided that the necessary nexus with the armed conflict and the other legal elements of the crime are established.
Ntaganda was convicted of rape and sexual slavery involving girls who were child soldiers. The consequences of these crimes, including the social difficulties faced by children born as a result of sexual violence, were also considered in the reparations proceedings.
Despite the significance of this development, Grey points to another gap: reproductive violence was not brought as an independent charge in the Ntaganda case either. In her view, certain facts in the case could have justified examining the charge of forced pregnancy, but this possibility was not fully pursued.
The significance of this judgment for the issues examined by Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch is clear. If an adolescent within an armed group is subjected to violence by commanders or other members, their membership in that same group does not necessarily prevent the conduct from being examined under specific war-crime provisions.
This issue raises new legal questions, particularly in relation to accounts of internal detention, sexual abuse, forced marriage and violence against those seeking to leave.
However, the Ntaganda jurisprudence does not mean that every act of violence within an armed group automatically constitutes a war crime. The existence of an armed conflict meeting the relevant criteria, the connection between the conduct and that conflict, and the specific elements of the alleged crime must each be examined independently.
Uganda: Reproduction as a Means of Sustaining an Armed Group
In cases concerning the Lord’s Resistance Army in Uganda, Grey encounters a different pattern. Here, pregnancy and reproduction were sometimes presented not as obstacles to the group’s activities but as means of reproducing its future manpower.
According to a 2022 report by the UN Secretary-General cited in the article, thousands of adolescent girls were abducted by the group, and some were forced to bear children before reaching sufficient physical and psychological maturity. The number of children born as a result of such violence has been estimated at approximately 8,000.
In the case of Dominic Ongwen, the International Criminal Court convicted an individual of the crime of forced pregnancy for the first time. The conviction was issued in 2021 and upheld on appeal in 2022. The victims concerned in the proven forced-pregnancy charges were adults at the time of the relevant conduct, but the jurisprudence established also has implications for examining crimes against child victims.
The case of Joseph Kony represents another stage in this development. In its charging documents, the ICC Prosecutor referred to the forced impregnation of numerous abducted women and girls, including girls under the age of 15. The charges against Kony were confirmed in absentia in November 2025; however, confirmation of charges is not equivalent to a conviction.
By comparing the Ugandan cases, Grey demonstrates that an armed group’s objectives in controlling reproduction may differ. One group may prevent women from becoming pregnant in order to preserve their combat capacity, while another may regard reproduction as a means of expanding the next generation of its forces.
The common feature in both situations is the denial of individuals’ control over their bodies and reproductive decisions. This finding is important for research into the internal structures of armed groups because it shifts attention away from their military appearance towards how they regulate their members’ private lives. Nevertheless, without specific evidence, the Ugandan armed group’s organised reproductive practices cannot be attributed to Kurdish armed groups.
Colombia: Pregnancy as an Obstacle to Being a Soldier
In Colombia, the issue emerged in a different form. In a case examined by the country’s Constitutional Court in 2019, a woman using the pseudonym “Helena” recounted that she had joined the armed group FARC at the age of 14 and had been forced to use injectable contraception.
She later became pregnant and, according to the findings examined by the Court, commanders forced her to undergo an abortion in the seventh month of pregnancy against her wishes. She was approximately 18 years old at the time of the forced abortion, although the imposed use of contraception had begun during her childhood.
The Colombian Constitutional Court assessed this conduct within the framework of violations of international humanitarian law and war crimes, and recognised the victim’s right to reparation.
A subsequent development took place within Colombia’s Special Jurisdiction for Peace. In October 2024, six former FARC leaders faced a series of charges related to child recruitment and crimes against children in Case No. 07. The charges included sexual and reproductive violence within the group, forced prevention of pregnancy and forced abortion. At the time Grey’s article was written, no final ruling had yet been issued on all the factual and legal grounds underlying these charges.
The central point in the Colombian analysis is the relationship between combat effectiveness and control over women’s bodies. In a structure where all members are expected to remain continuously active in military operations, pregnancy and childcare responsibilities may be regarded as incompatible with the commanders’ preferred model of a fighting force.
Grey notes that despite FARC’s claims of gender equality between women and men, the burden of contraception was effectively imposed on women. The military structure reproduced a masculine model of the ideal combatant, turning women’s reproductive capacity into an issue over which commanders made decisions.
For Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch, this section provides a basis for examining the gap between claims of gender equality and the actual living conditions of women within armed groups.
In Hira’s account concerning PAK, gender discrimination, restrictions on personal freedom and pressure to marry are raised. Such accounts may provide material for research into women’s autonomy within military structures. However, unless specific evidence of reproductive control is available, they cannot be treated as equivalent to Helena’s case.
From Victim Testimony to Command Responsibility
The final section of the article addresses a practical question: how can reproductive violence be documented in a way that prevents it from being overlooked in judicial proceedings?
Grey considers specialised training for interviewers, early evidence collection, access to psychological services and attention to cultural and local terminology essential. In her view, victims do not always describe their experiences using precise legal or medical terms. Sometimes an account of illness, pregnancy loss or pressure from a commander may point to an issue that cannot be identified without specialised questions.
In such cases, direct testimony from the victim or an eyewitness, medical records, messages and complaints made at the time of the incident, documents concerning commanders’ orders, and evidence that they knew of their subordinates’ conduct are all important.
The author also addresses command responsibility. Such responsibility may be examined on the basis of direct commission, ordering, participation in a crime or, where the relevant conditions are met, a knowing commander’s failure to take all necessary and reasonable measures to prevent, stop or punish crimes committed by subordinates.
In terms of criminal classifications, the article identifies several possible legal avenues. Depending on the specific elements established, certain reproductive acts may be prosecuted as forced pregnancy, enforced sterilisation, sexual slavery or other forms of sexual violence. In other circumstances, offences such as enslavement, torture, other inhumane acts or gender-based persecution may be examined within the framework of crimes against humanity.
Grey emphasises that, for crimes against humanity, the contextual requirements under Article 7 of the Rome Statute are significant. These include a widespread or systematic attack directed against a civilian population and the connection between the conduct and that attack. Therefore, even severe and harmful acts cannot be classified as crimes against humanity without examining the required contextual elements.
This discussion has clear implications for documentation by Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch. Interviews with former members of armed groups must distinguish between what a witness personally experienced, what they directly observed and what they heard from others. Furthermore, confidentiality, the victim’s informed consent and the prevention of retraumatisation during interviews must take priority over information gathering.
Conclusion: Cases That Must Be Examined Beyond Child Recruitment
The central conclusion of Rosemary Grey’s research is that girls’ experiences within armed groups cannot be confined to the two categories of child soldier recruitment and sexual violence. Some victims are simultaneously subjected to military coercion, control over their family lives, deprivation of liberty, reproductive violence and lasting social and medical consequences. If these experiences are not properly documented from the outset, they may also be overlooked in subsequent judicial proceedings.
Several cases published by Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch have direct or thematic connections with this conclusion:
First, Hira’s case and PAK. Her account of joining the group at the age of 15, living within its military structure, facing pressure to marry and experiencing restrictions on leaving is relevant to the issues of power relations, individual autonomy and child protection discussed by Grey. This case may be particularly important for examining coercion in relationships within armed groups, although the materials referred to do not establish that a specific reproductive crime was committed against Hira.
Second, Delzhin’s account. According to Hira, Delzhin was subjected to torture and forced marriage after attempting to leave the group. This allegation can be compared with the Sierra Leone examples in terms of the relationship between punishment for attempting to leave, the exercise of control and coercion into a family relationship. However, any criminal conclusion would require independent investigation, testimony and additional supporting evidence.
Third, Kaveh Shahbazi’s case and Komala. Recruitment through social media, promises of material benefits and difficulties leaving the group relate to the article’s broader discussion of the limitations of the traditional concept of child soldiers. The significance of this case lies in demonstrating the recruitment and control of adolescents, not in establishing reproductive violence.
Fourth, the account of a 15-year-old former Komala member. The organisation’s report concerning an individual who was recruited with promises of being sent to Europe and spent approximately 25 days in harsh camp conditions demonstrates that the examination of children’s circumstances must begin at the recruitment stage and extend to their living conditions, assigned activities and freedom to leave.
Fifth, the case of Omid Hosseini and PJAK. Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch’s report on his recruitment at the age of 16, military training and subsequent death demonstrates the importance of documenting age, recruitment circumstances and the military use of adolescents. This case concerns child soldier recruitment and should not be linked to sexual or reproductive violence without supporting evidence.
These comparisons do not constitute an endorsement of Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch’s allegations by Rosemary Grey; her article does not examine Kurdish armed groups. Their value lies in showing how the legal methodology developed in her research can help formulate more precise questions about existing cases.
A further conclusion emerges from Grey’s findings: a child’s membership in an armed group must not result in the denial of their right to protection from violence committed by members of that same group. Likewise, an armed group’s potential responsibility is not limited to its conduct on the battlefield. Commanders’ treatment of members, the regulation of their private lives and the possibility of leaving the organisation may also be significant under international law.
For Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch, this research provides an opportunity to examine cases involving child recruitment, forced marriage, violence within armed groups and deprivation of liberty through a more detailed documentation framework, where sufficient evidence is available.
Several questions remain: To what extent have the testimonies collected from women who have left armed groups examined their autonomy in marriage, reproduction and access to healthcare? Have the experiences of individuals who joined these groups as adolescents been limited to recruitment and military training, or have other potential forms of harm also been documented? And if evidence of violence within armed groups emerges, do existing documentation mechanisms have the capacity to preserve it for independent and fair legal proceedings?
Rosemary Grey’s research does not answer all these questions. However, it demonstrates that the first obstacle to accountability is sometimes not the absence of law, but the failure to recognise conduct that should have been investigated from the outset.
—
References
- Rosemary Grey, “Reproductive Violence against Child Soldiers,” Leiden Journal of International Law, Vol. 39, No. 2 (June 2026), pp. 563–587. Published online on 10 April 2026.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0922156525100654
- Rosemary Grey, Prosecuting Sexual and Gender-Based Crimes at the International Criminal Court: Practice, Progress and Potential, Cambridge University Press, 2019.
- Rosemary Grey, “The ICC’s First ‘Forced Pregnancy’ Case in Historical Perspective,” Journal of International Criminal Justice, Vol. 15, No. 5 (2017), pp. 905–930.
https://doi.org/10.1093/jicj/mqx051
- Prosecutor v. Thomas Lubanga Dyilo, Trial Judgment, ICC-01/04-01/06-2842, 5 April 2012; Appeal Judgment, ICC-01/04-01/06-3121-Red, 1 December 2014.
- Prosecutor v. Bosco Ntaganda, Trial Judgment, ICC-01/04-02/06-2359, 8 July 2019; Appeal Judgment, ICC-01/04-02/06-2666-Red, 30 March 2021.
- Prosecutor v. Dominic Ongwen, Trial Judgment, ICC-02/04-01/15-1762-Red, 4 February 2021; Appeal Judgment, ICC-02/04-01/15-2022-Red, 15 December 2022.
- Prosecutor v. Joseph Kony, Decision on the Confirmation of Charges in Absentia, ICC-02/04-01/05-633, 6 November 2025.
- Corte Constitucional de Colombia, Sentencia SU-599/19, 11 December 2019.
- Jurisdicción Especial para la Paz (JEP), Case 07, Order No. 05 of 2024, 9 October 2024.
- ICC Office of the Prosecutor, Policy on Gender-Based Crimes, December 2023.
- UN Women and Global Justice Center, Documenting Reproductive Violence: Unveiling Opportunities, Challenges, and Legal Pathways for UN Investigative Mechanisms, 2024.
- Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch, “From Online Deception to Escaping the Camp: Hira’s Account,” series of interviews, September 2026.
- Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch, “From Instagram Promises to Beatings: The Account of an Adolescent Who Wanted to Leave Komala,” 23 September 2026.
- Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch, “A 15-Year-Old, Twenty-Five Days in the Mountains: An Account from the Ranks of Komala,” 27 August 2026.
- Iranian Kurdistan Human Rights Watch, “The Killing of an Iranian Kurdish Child Soldier in PJAK,” 24 July 2025.





